
PCP vs HP Compared
Let's compare them and see which works for you!
Hire Purchase
Think of Hire Purchase like a loan tied to a car. You pay a deposit, and then you pay off the rest of the car’s value in equal monthly installments over typically two to five years ,although there are longer terms.
The main thing to know about HP is that when the last payment is made, the car is 100% yours. There is no big final bill and no restrictions on what you do with the car while you're paying for it.
Best for: People who keep their cars for a long time (5+ years) or drivers who do high mileage.
Ownership: You are the registered keeper, but the finance company owns the car until the very last payment is made.
Personal Contract Purchase (PCP): The Flexible Option
PCP is a bit more calculated. Instead of paying for the whole car, you are essentially paying for the car's depreciation - the value the car is expected to lose while you’re driving it.
Because you're not paying off the full value of the vehicle, your monthly payments are lower than HP. However, there is a catch: the Balloon Payment or Guaranteed Future Value. At the end of the deal, you don't own the car unless you pay the large final lump sum or GFV.
You have three choices at the end of a PCP deal, which are based around the GFV.
Hand it back: Give the keys back and walk away (if the car is in good condition and under the mileage limit).
Trade it in: Use any equity in the car (if it’s worth more than the balloon/GFV) as a deposit for your next car. For example if the GFV is worth
Keep it: Pay the balloon payment to own the car outright.
Pros and Cons: PCP vs. HP
Feature | Hire Purchase (HP) | Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) |
Monthly Cost | Higher - you’re paying off the whole car. | Lower - you’re only paying for depreciation. |
End of Deal options | You own the car automatically. | You must pay a Balloon or GFV to own it fully. |
Mileage Limits | None. Drive as much as you like. | Strict limits. Your contract will have a mileage limit. If you hand the car back, you could be charged an excess mileage charge from a few pence per mile on cheaper cars to 50p to £1 on some high-end models |
Total Interest | Lower - you pay the debt off faster. | Higher - you pay interest on the Balloon or GFV too. |
Flexibility | Lower - you’re committed to buying it. | Higher - you can choose what to do at the end. |
Consumer Protection | Once you have paid half the total amount payable, you can hand it back to the finance company with nothing further to pay.* Regulated agreements only | Once you have paid half the total amount payable, you can hand it back to the finance company with nothing further to pay.* Regulated agreements only |
Finance Benefits | If the car you buy has quality issues after you buy it,, the finance company will help you to resolve them with the dealer. If not, you can often reject the car and unwind the deal. | If the car you buy has quality issues after you buy it,, the finance company will help you to resolve them with the dealer. If not, you can often reject the car and unwind the deal |
The Maths
To see how this actually hits your bank account, let's look at a £20,000 used car financed over 4 years (48 months) with a £2,000 deposit and an 8.9% APR.
On HP: Your monthly payment would be roughly £444. After 4 years, you've paid about £23,312 in total and you own a car that might be worth around £10,000.
On PCP: Your monthly payment would be roughly £275. After 4 years, you've paid about £15,200. To keep the car, you’d have to pay a balloon of £8,000. Total cost to own: £25,200.
The Verdict: PCP is more expensive if you want to keep the car forever, but it’s much better for your monthly cash flow if you plan to upgrade in 4 years anyway.
These are examples. For more exact figures, try our car finance calculator.
What to consider
Beyond the monthly payments, there are two things that often catch people out:
1. The Mileage
On PCP, you have to agree to a mileage limit (e.g., 10,000 miles a year). If you go over that, the finance company will charge you for every extra mile, but only if you hand the car back. If you’re a high-mileage driver, HP is often the safer bet because it gives you more freedom.
2. Maintenance and Condition
If you plan to hand a PCP car back, it needs to be in good condition (allowing for fair wear and tear). If there are big dents or scuffs, the lender could bill you for them. There is a BVRLA guide which explains how this works. You can find out more about that here
Which one should you choose?
Lean towards HP if:
You definitely want to own the car at the end.
You do more than 20,000 miles a year.
You want the simplest deal with the lowest total interest cost.
You plan to keep the car until it stops running.
Lean towards PCP if:
You want the lowest monthly payment.
You like to change your car regularly.
You want a more expensive car than your monthly budget would allow on HP.
You want the safety net of being able to hand the car back if the car's value drops unexpectedly.
As always, these are guidelines, not rules. As long as you understand the pros and cons of HP and PCP, you are in a good place to decide which is best for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change from PCP to HP mid-contract?
Not directly. You would usually have to settle your current PCP deal (get a settlement figure) and start a new HP agreement. This can be expensive, so it’s better to get the choice right at the start.
Which is easier to get approved for?
Generally, there isn't much difference. Lenders look at your affordability and credit score for both. However, because HP payments are higher, the "affordability" check might be slightly stricter than for a PCP deal with lower payments.
Is PCP just renting a car?
It feels like it, but legally it’s a purchase agreement. You are the registered keeper on the V5C logbook, and you are responsible for insurance, taxing, and MOTing the vehicle.
Does PCP have a higher interest rate?
Not necessarily. The APR (the percentage) is often the same. However, because you aren't paying off the Balloon part of the loan during the term, you are paying interest on that large chunk of money for the whole 4 years. This means the total amount of interest you pay is usually higher on PCP for the same amount of money borrowed.
Can I sell the car halfway through? Technically, no. Practically, yes. The finance company owns the car until the end. However, you can settle the deal at any time. You get a settlement figure from the lender, pay it off (often by selling the car to a dealer), and the deal is closed. You sell the car to the dealer, they pay off the finance and deduct the settlement figure from the proceed of the deal.
Can I pay the balloon payment in installments? No. You either pay it in one go or take out a new re-finance agreement to cover it, which means you'll be paying interest for even longer.
Use our Finance Calculator to compare PCP and HP quotes side-by-side
What is the GMFV or Balloon on a PCP?
Simply put, a balloon payment is a large lump sum you owe at the very end of your finance agreement if you want to keep the car. Here is the broker’s view"on how it works, why it exists, and how to make sure it doesn't catch you out.
What exactly is a Balloon Payment?
When you take out a PCP (Personal Contract Purchase) deal, you aren't paying off the full price of the car. Instead, the lender calculates what they think the car will be worth in three or four years’ time. They defer that amount and push the payment of it away until the end of your contract.
This amount is your GFV/balloon payment. Because you aren't paying this chunk off every month, your monthly bills are much lower than they would be on a traditional loan.
The GMFV: Your safety net
In the fine print, the balloon payment is often called the Guaranteed Minimum Future Value (GMFV), or sometimes GFV
The Guaranteed part is important. It means the lender is taking the risk on the car's value, not you. If the used car market crashes and your car is worth £2,000 less than the balloon payment at the end of the deal, you don't have to worry. You can just hand the keys back and walk away. The lender has to swallow the loss.
What is the Equity bit?
Most people hope to have equity at the end of their deal0 this is when the car is worth more than the balloon payment. You can use that extra cash as a deposit for your next car.
To give yourself the best chance of having equity, you need to be honest about your mileage. If you tell the lender you'll do 5,000 miles a year but you actually do 10,000, your car will be worth less than they expected. This eats into your equity and could even result in you being underwater (where the car is worth less than the balloon).
Pros and Cons: The Balloon Payment
Pros | Cons |
Cheaper Monthly Bills: By deferring a big chunk of the vehicle cost, you keep more cash in your pocket every month. | Ownership Barrier: You don't own the car until that final bill is paid. It’s a big hurdle if you decide you want to keep it. |
Market Protection: If the car's value plummets, you aren't stuck with the loss- the lender is. | Interest Costs: You are paying interest on that balloon amount for the whole 4 years, which makes the total deal more expensive than HP in terms of interest per £1000 borrowed |
Flexibility: You have 3 or 4 years to decide if you actually like the car enough to buy it. | Mileage: You have to stick to mileage and condition rules to avoid extra charges at the end. (You don’t have to pay any excess mileage if you trade the car in or buy it outright, only if you hand it back.) |
What happens at the end of my contract?
When you reach the end of your contract, you have to choose one of these three paths:
Ownership: You pay the balloon payment in full. The car is now 100% yours. Most people either save up for this or take out a new, smaller loan (refinancing) to cover it.
Hand the Car Back: You give the car back to the lender. As long as you haven't gone over your mileage and the car isn't damaged, you owe nothing.
Trade-In/Part Exchange: You get a value from a dealer against another car. They pay off the balloon payment for you. If the car is worth more than the balloon, they give you the difference to use as a deposit on your next car.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to pay the balloon payment?
No. It is completely optional. You only pay it if you want to keep the car. If you don’t want to pay it, you just hand the car back or trade it in.
Can I refinance the balloon?
Yes. If you want to keep the car but don't have £10,000 sitting in the bank, you can take out a new finance agreement to pay off the balloon. Just keep in mind that you'll be paying interest for a few more years.
What happens if I can’t afford the balloon but want the car?
If you can't pay it and can't get a loan to refinance it, you will unfortunately have to hand the car back. This is why we always recommend checking your "equity position" about 6 months before the end of the deal.
Why is my balloon so high?
Balloons are higher for cars that hold their value well (like Porsches or Range Rovers) and lower for cars that depreciate quickly. A high balloon is actually a compliment to the car—it means the market thinks it’s a high-quality asset.
Is it a "hidden fee"?
No. By law, the balloon payment must be clearly shown on your finance agreement before you sign.
Is a lease purchase balloon the same?
No. On a lease purchase the balloon is not a guaranteed figure, so you are not protected in the same way, which is why LP agreements are reserved for businesses and High-Net-Worth individuals.

